This is a picture of the table after I had cleaned it up and given a couple coats of Java gel stain.
The wood was in pretty bad shape but I cleaned it up with a power washer. If you have never used one of those things let me tell you they are awesome! It took off dirt I didn't even realize was there. The wood looked great after it had dried. I wanted an authentic rustic look so I left the nails in the boards and cut them off on the back side.
I used the table as a guide and cut the wood a few inches longer on both ends for an over hang and about an inch on the long sides. I made the cuts so the nails were staggered along each board.
I tried two different stains, Dark Walnut and Java. I decided I like the Dark Walnut the best. It is at the top of the wood.
After the stain, I gave the boards three coats of semi-gloss polyurethane. I should have tried that along with the stain because it is just a bit too shiny for my taste. My husband helped me attach the boards to the table with wood screws.
It isn't too bad for something that I just wanted to try out. I will probably end up using it in the new garage rec room.